Hiring Your First Employee: A Practical Checklist
A practical guide to defining the role, preparing essential hiring and payroll steps, and setting up a new employee's first day.
A first hire involves more than finding a candidate. This checklist covers role planning, employment setup, required records, and a practical first-day plan.
Define the role before you post
Start by identifying the work the company needs done and the outcomes the new employee should be able to contribute toward. Separate essential qualifications from skills that can be learned, and decide who will manage the role and provide day-to-day direction.
Use those decisions to shape the job description, interview criteria, and first 90-day expectations. Confirm that the proposed workload and compensation fit the company's budget before opening the search.
Before you make an offer
Most first-time employers focus entirely on finding the right person and forget to build the infrastructure needed to actually employ them legally. The time to build that infrastructure is before you make an offer, not after.
- Get your EIN: You need a federal Employer Identification Number from the IRS before you can run payroll. Apply at IRS.gov. It takes minutes to get your EIN online.
- Choose a payroll provider: You must withhold federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare from every paycheck. Use a payroll service like Gusto, Rippling, or ADP rather than trying to manage this manually.
- Register for state payroll taxes: Every state has its own income tax withholding and unemployment insurance registration process. Register in your state before your first payroll.
- Check workers' compensation requirements: Coverage requirements vary by state and may depend on the employer, workforce, and work performed. Confirm the applicable requirements with the relevant state agency and a qualified insurance provider before work begins.
- Create a compliant offer letter: Your offer letter should clearly state compensation, start date, whether the role is at-will, whether the offer is contingent on background check or other conditions, and confirm exempt or non-exempt status.
Work authorization and payroll records
Complete Form I-9 within the required federal timeline and follow current U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services instructions for examining documents. Some employers may use an authorized alternative procedure when they meet its requirements.
Your payroll provider will require the employee to complete Form W-4, which governs federal income tax withholding. Most states have equivalent state withholding forms.
New hire reporting
Employers generally have new-hire reporting responsibilities, but the reporting process and deadline depend on the state. Confirm the applicable instructions with the state agency and check whether your payroll provider will submit the report.
The employee handbook
A handbook can help communicate workplace policies and processes, but appropriate content depends on the employer, workforce, and applicable law. Topics to review may include equal employment opportunity, how employees raise concerns, pay practices, time off, and any jurisdiction-specific requirements. Have qualified employment counsel review policies that require legal interpretation.
Written policies do not replace following applicable law or responding appropriately to workplace concerns.
What comes next
Additional federal, state, and local requirements may apply as your workforce grows. Thresholds and coverage rules vary by law, location, and employer. Track the rules that apply to your organization using current agency guidance and qualified employment counsel.
TalentForge360 offers a Free HR Consultation for companies at any stage of growth. If you are making your first hire or scaling quickly, the review can help identify exactly what you need to have in place without promising a formal audit or legal advice.
Budget for the full employment cost
Salary or hourly wages are only part of the cost of adding an employee. Depending on the role and location, also account for employer payroll taxes, workers' compensation, benefits, equipment, software, recruiting, and the time required for onboarding and management.
Estimate each cost using current information from your payroll, benefits, and insurance providers. The total varies by compensation, location, benefits choices, and employer circumstances, so avoid relying on a single multiplier as a substitute for a tailored estimate.